Case summary

Mysterious invaders called the Sea Peoples swept across the eastern Mediterranean around 1177 BC and destroyed the great civilizations of the Bronze Age.

Verdict: Mixture

The Sea Peoples were real and recorded by Egypt, but drought, famine, earthquakes, revolts and the failure of an interdependent trade system all played a part, and their relative weight is still debated.

Within a few generations after 1200 BC the Hittite Empire vanished, Ugarit and the Mycenaean palaces were destroyed and international trade collapsed. Egypt blamed seaborne invaders, the Sea Peoples, whom it fought in 1177 BC. Climate records now show severe drought at the same time, and Eric Cline describes a 'perfect storm' of drought, famine, earthquakes, migration and revolt that brought down an interconnected system.

Do you believe it?

Be the first to vote.

Line drawing of the Medinet Habu relief of Ramesses III's naval battle, with the king and his archers shooting into the ships of the Sea Peoples

Photo: Unknown artist in pay of Ramesses III, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons Source

In the thirteenth century BC the eastern Mediterranean looked like a stable club of great powers. Egypt, the Hittite Empire in Anatolia, Mycenaean Greece, Cyprus, the trading kingdom of Ugarit on the Syrian coast, Assyria and Kassite Babylonia exchanged letters, princesses, copper, tin, grain and luxury goods. Within a few generations after 1200 BC most of that world had broken apart. Palaces burned or were abandoned, writing disappeared from Greece for centuries, the Hittite state vanished, and trade routes fell silent. The episode is known as the Late Bronze Age collapse, and the question of what caused it has been argued for more than a century.

What happened

The clearest snapshot comes from Ugarit, whose archives run almost to the moment the city fell, sometime between about 1190 and 1185 BC. Its last letters, as summarized by the archaeologist Eric Cline of George Washington University, speak of enemy ships approaching, fields laid waste, drought and hunger. The city was destroyed and never rebuilt.

In Egypt, Ramesses III recorded on the walls of his mortuary temple at Medinet Habu that a confederation of foreign peoples had come out of the islands and swept away one kingdom after another before attacking Egypt by land and sea. The temple reliefs show a sea battle in which Egyptian archers shoot down warriors wearing horned helmets and feathered headdresses. Modern scholars call these groups the Sea Peoples, and Cline uses the year of their second assault on Egypt, 1177 BC, as a shorthand for the whole collapse, much as 476 AD stands in for the fall of Rome.

The investigation

For much of the twentieth century the Sea Peoples carried the blame. The French Egyptologist Gaston Maspero helped popularize that view in the nineteenth century, largely on the strength of the Medinet Habu inscription. The trouble, as Cline points out, is that inland powers such as Kassite Babylonia, Elam and Assyria also declined although no raiders from the sea ever reached them, and, as climate researchers noted in 2013, nobody knows exactly who the Sea Peoples were, where they came from or where they went afterward.

Science has since added the environment to the case. In 2013 a team led by David Kaniewski analyzed pollen from a sediment core at the Larnaca Salt Lake in Cyprus and compared it with an earlier record from Gibala-Tell Tweini on the Syrian coast. Both showed the onset of a long drought around 1200 BC that lasted for roughly three centuries, and the authors argued that famine drove some of the population movements remembered as the Sea Peoples. In 2023 Sturt Manning and colleagues reported tree-ring and isotope data from juniper timbers at Gordion in central Anatolia showing an unusually severe dry spell lasting about three consecutive years, around 1198 to 1196 BC. In a society that could ride out one bad harvest but not several in a row, that may have been a tipping point. Excavators now think the Hittite capital, Hattusa, was not stormed by invaders but abandoned and emptied by its own administration, and only later set on fire.

The explanations

Cline’s influential answer, set out in his 2014 book 1177 B.C.: The Year Civilization Collapsed, is a perfect storm. He argues that there is evidence for climate change, drought and famine, earthquakes, invasions and internal revolts all at roughly the same time, and ranks them in about that order of importance. Any one of them might have been survivable. Together, in an economy where every kingdom depended on long-distance trade with the others, each shock amplified the next until the system itself failed. In that reading the Sea Peoples are as much symptom as cause, uprooted communities moving in search of food and land.

Not every scholar accepts a single grand narrative. Conditions varied from region to region: some cities were sacked in war, while others seem to have been emptied first and burned later. Even for Hattusa, the historian Guy Middleton has written that some specific event, possibly one that will never be recovered, must have triggered the final abandonment.

Where it stands

The broad shape of the crisis is not in doubt. The tablets, the ruined palaces and the climate records all point to a drawn-out unraveling across roughly a century rather than a single catastrophe. What remains unresolved is the weighting: how much drought, how much war, how much earthquake damage and how much political failure, and in what order, for each kingdom. The Sea Peoples are still unidentified, and the debate continues.

Case file

Status
Open
Site
Eastern Mediterranean: Ugarit, Hattusa, Mycenaean Greece, Cyprus and Egypt
Coordinates
35.6020, 35.7820
Date
1200 BCE to 1100 BCE
Evidence
Document Physical trace
Investigated by
Eric H. Cline; David Kaniewski and colleagues (2013); Sturt W. Manning and colleagues (2023)
Case ID
UX-0758
Last updated

References

  1. Interview: The Mysterious Bronze Age Collapse with Eric Cline James Wiener, World History Encyclopedia, 2019-09-19 Interview
  2. Environmental roots of the Late Bronze Age crisis David Kaniewski et al., PLOS ONE 8(8), 2013-08-14 Journal
  3. Severe multi-year drought coincident with Hittite collapse around 1198–1196 BC Sturt W. Manning et al., Nature 614, 2023-02-08 Journal
  4. Late Bronze Age collapse Wikipedia Website

Reader reports

What readers have seen, heard or found since. Reports are read before they appear and may be used in a video.

No reader reports yet. Seen something? You could be the first.

Have you seen it? Send a report
Shown as an initial.
Never shown. Only if we need to follow up.