Case summary

A patch of desert in northern Mexico blocks radio signals and spins compass needles, draws meteorites and rockets out of the sky, and is a meeting place for extraterrestrials.

Verdict: Mostly False

A US test rocket really did crash there in July 1970, but researchers working in the area for decades report radios and compasses that behave normally, and the legend grew up after the crash, apparently to draw tourists.

In July 1970 an Athena test rocket fired from Utah toward White Sands overshot into the Mapimí desert of Durango, Mexico, carrying two small vials of radioactive cobalt-57. The US Air Force spent weeks finding it and hauled away the contaminated soil. Out of that clean-up grew the Zona del Silencio, a place where radios supposedly die, compasses spin and visitors meet aliens. Scientists at the biosphere reserve that overlaps the zone say their radios work fine, and an anthropologist who lived there traced the legend to locals hoping for tourist money.

Do you believe it?

Be the first to vote.

A blue road sign pointing to the biosphere reserve stands on flat desert scrub while visitors search the ground in the area known as the Zone of Silence

Photo: Isaac Ramos Chavira, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons Source

The Bolsón de Mapimí is a vast closed basin in the Chihuahuan Desert of northern Mexico, ranch country of creosote, cactus and salt flats near the point where the states of Durango, Chihuahua and Coahuila touch. Part of it became a UNESCO biosphere reserve a few years after the events below, and is home to a research station and to the rare Bolsón tortoise. Part of it, depending on whom you ask, is La Zona del Silencio: a stretch of ground where radio broadcasts fade to nothing, compass needles wander, meteorites fall unusually often and visitors sometimes meet tall, fair-haired beings from elsewhere.

What happened

The one solid event in the story took place on July 11, 1970. The US Air Force launched an Athena test rocket, flight V-123-D, from its Green River test site in Utah. Athenas were used to fling dummy warheads back into the atmosphere at missile speeds, and they were supposed to come down on the White Sands range in New Mexico. This one went wrong in flight and kept going. A memorandum to President Nixon from Henry Kissinger, later released and published by the National Security Archive, put the impact 180 to 200 miles south of the border in a thinly populated corner of Durango and noted that Mexico had agreed to help with the search.

The re-entry vehicle carried two small containers of cobalt-57, a radioactive isotope used to measure how much of the nose cone’s heat shield burned away. That turned a lost piece of hardware into a contamination problem. According to Andrea Kaus, an anthropologist who lived and worked in the reserve between 1988 and 1990, searchers hired from the nearby city of Gómez Palacio combed the desert while aircraft flew overhead, and the wreck was found after about three weeks, nose down in a sand dune. A local man, Jaime González, led a guard to keep onlookers away. The Americans laid an airstrip and a temporary railroad spur, dug out the dune and shipped the contaminated soil north. Sources differ on small details: Kaus gives the launch date as July 2 and places the crash just inside Chihuahua, while the Air Force documents say July 11 and Durango.

How the legend grew

Kaus, writing in a 1992 dissertation later excerpted online, concluded that the Zone of Silence was invented after the clean-up, when a few local men realized how much attention the empty desert had drawn and began talking about a hotel. Accounts disagree on who added what, but within a few years regional newspapers, then national media, were reporting that magnetic forces in the ground stopped radio transmissions and had pulled the rocket down. The 1969 fall of the Allende meteorite in Chihuahua was folded in as proof that the place attracted objects from space. An American author, Gerry Hunt, sold the zone to English-language readers in a mass-market paperback that promised giant UFOs and grotesque animals.

Visitors, known locally as zoneros, followed. Kaus counted more than 650 people turning up at the research station in 1989 alone asking for directions to the zone, and found that its location kept moving: first the crash site, later a spot where an oil-company engineer said his equipment failed, and eventually wherever a guide chose to take a carload of tourists.

The explanations

The testable part of the legend fails the test. Kaus and the staff of the reserve used radios and compasses without trouble, and researchers there have said the same to journalists since. In a 2019 Skeptoid episode Brian Dunning pointed out that a buried magnetic mass, even if one existed, would not block radio waves at all, and that the Meteoritical Bulletin lists only two small finds near Mapimí. The Allende meteorite came down well to the west and is a stony type that is not magnetic. The mutations visitors describe have ordinary causes: the triangles on tortoise shells are a normal pattern, and a local prickly pear turns purple in dry spells. Compasses that seem to swing on their own are easy to manage with a small hidden magnet.

Where it stands

The rocket crash is documented and the radioactive clean-up was real, if long kept quiet. Everything layered on top of it, from the dead radios to the aliens, has no support beyond the stories themselves. The zone still draws tourists and the occasional film crew, much to the frustration of the ranchers and scientists who share the desert with them.

Case file

Status
Closed
Phenomenon
Radio Signal, UFO
Site
Bolsón de Mapimí, near the meeting point of Durango, Chihuahua and Coahuila (Mapimí Biosphere Reserve)
Coordinates
26.6833, -103.7500
Date
July 11, 1970
Evidence
Document Physical trace Testimony only
Investigated by
US Air Force recovery team with the Mexican government (1970); Andrea Kaus, University of California, Riverside (1988–90); Brian Dunning, Skeptoid (2019)
Case ID
UX-1201
Last updated

References

  1. USAF Accidentally Launched Rocket into Mexico's Mapimi Desert 45 Years Ago Michael Barclay, Unredacted: The National Security Archive Blog, 2015-07-13 Archive
  2. The Zone of Silence in Northern Mexico: scientific marvel or just fiction? Andrea Kaus, MexConnect (excerpted from a 1992 UC Riverside dissertation), 1997-01-01 Journal
  3. Mexico's Zone of Silence Brian Dunning, Skeptoid #682, 2019-07-02 Website
  4. The mysterious desert linked to aliens and mutated animals Claire Asher, BBC Science Focus Website
  5. Mapimí Silent Zone Wikipedia Website

Reader reports

What readers have seen, heard or found since. Reports are read before they appear and may be used in a video.

No reader reports yet. Seen something? You could be the first.

Have you seen it? Send a report
Shown as an initial.
Never shown. Only if we need to follow up.