Verdict: Unproven
New York
Verdict: Mostly True
Acquired Savant Syndrome
Verdict: Unproven
The Death of Mary Rogers, the Beautiful Cigar Girl
Verdict: Unproven
Vincent Lamouris
Verdict: Unproven
The Pine Bush UFO Sightings
Verdict: True
The Peekskill Meteorite
Verdict: Legend
Mount Misery Road
Verdict: Legend
Lake Ronkonkoma and the Lady of the Lake
Verdict: Unproven
Judge Crater
Verdict: Legend
Major André and the Ghost of Sleepy Hollow
Verdict: Hoax
The Amityville Horror
Verdict: Legend
Triskaidekaphobia
Verdict: False